Save The Cursed — Tabletop curse design | savethecursed.net
Compare the published effect options without combining them, and note what counterplay each one leaves open.
The disadvantage option targets a chosen ability and applies to ability checks and saving throws made with it. Counterplay is straightforward: avoid relying on that ability, or remove the curse.
The damage option adds 1d8 necrotic damage when the caster damages the target with an attack roll or a spell. It is the most direct option and the easiest to track, because it triggers on a specific event.
On narrow screens, swipe or scroll the plate sideways.
The combat option forces a Wisdom save at the start of each turn or the target must take the Dodge action. It changes what the target can do on its turn rather than what it can withstand.
Each option leaves different counterplay. The disadvantage option can be routed around; the damage option can be survived; the combat option can be escaped by a successful save. Choosing one option is what makes the counterplay legible.
Do not stack options. A curse that combines all three is hard to track and hard to remove fairly, because the removal clause has to lift several unrelated penalties at once.
Further reading